Padma Venkatraman lives in North Kingstown, Rhode Island. The Providence Journal’s Sam Coale called it a “fine, often heartbreaking first novel” and pointed out that, although he was not a “young” adult, he loved it and had not realized that it was categorized as such until it was pointed out to him. A book about hate crimes that's easy to love. Padma Venkatraman, Author. Padma Venkatraman lives in North Kingstown, Rhode Island. Padma Venkatraman tells us the story of two young girls who run away from home, due to issues with an abusive father and a sick mother. Her next novel, Born Behind Bars, is scheduled for October 2021 release. Also, similar to that novel, in this work, as well, we see the stories of humans and animals - an enslaved woman, an ocelot, and a thief. It follows two sisters, Viji and Rukku, as they run away from their abusive father and choose to live on the streets. Another book to win hearts, written by an award-winning author. In an effort to make a change, author Padma Venkatraman did something she’d classify as unusual. For a girl who’s grown up used to receiving applause … Padma Venkatraman plans to write new posts regularly in fall, to celebrate the Global Read Aloud project and ProjectLIT. Magical, meaningful and moving. Padma infuses her story with hope and bravery that will inspire readers." Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. They shrink our world by expanding our understanding and empathy. Padma Venkatraman’s inspiring story of a young girl’s struggle to regain her passion and find a new peace is told lyrically through verse that captures the beauty and mystery of India and the ancient bharatanatyam dance form. This poignant tale explores homelessness in a voice that rings true. ‎Preview and download books by Padma Venkatraman, including Climbing the Stairs, The Bridge Home and many more. Meet-the-Author Recording of The Bridge Home; Audio Excerpt from A Time to Dance; Video Book Trailer for A Time to Dance; Name Pronunciation with Padma Venkatraman; Our Original Resources 5 This book gives readers a glimpse into what it means to live in a traditional Indian joint family and of the restrictions imposed on people due to social and cultural norms. To learn more, about her book Climbing the Stairs, visit… More about Padma Venkatraman Very quickly, eleven-year-old Viji discovers how vulnerable they are in this uncaring, dangerous world. Another book to win hearts, written by an award-winning author. Magical, meaningful and moving. Max loves stories and longs to solve the mystery of what happened to his mother who disappeared when he was a baby. Padma Venkatraman’s inspiring story of a young girl’s struggle to regain her passion and find a new peace is told lyrically through verse that captures the beauty and mystery of India and the ancient bharatanatyam dance form. Error rating book. In these difficult and divisive times, I think it's particularly important for young people to have access to stories exploring a protagonist's inner strength and so I was intrigued by even the first draft, which I read long ago, and felt certain, upon reading it, that it would, for sure, soon be published - and I am delighted to see my prediction came true. You can also read her blog, padmasbooks.blogspot.com. Free download or read online Climbing the Stairs pdf (ePUB) book. Themes: Dance, India, Amputee, Disabilities, Abilities. Venkatraman's debut novel, Climbing the Stairs, was released to starred reviews in Booklist, Publishers Weekly and Voice of Youth Advocates (VOYA). She started a hashtag. Book Jacket Synopsis: Veda, a classical dance prodigy in India, lives and breathes dance–so when an accident leaves her a below-knee amputee, her dreams are shattered. The novel also received glowing reviews in Kirkus Reviews, School Library Journal, India New England News and India Currents. An oceanographer by training, she is the author of twenty books for young readers, published in India, on a variety of subjects. Thank you @kidlitexchange @penguinkids and @venkatraman.padma for the review copy of this book. The main characters of this historical, historical fiction story are , . An oceanographer by training, she is the author of twenty books for young readers, published in India, on a variety of subjects. 36 Resources12 Awards. In this book, McWilliams has created a female protagonis. Visit her at, Double Stars: The Story of Caroline Herschel. Padma Venkatraman lives in North Kingstown, Rhode Island. for a virtual, intergenerational book discussion of The Bridge Home, featuring the book’s author, Padma Venkatraman. I knew what entomology was, but this book introduced me to entomophagy, which I'd never heard of. A sustained effort is under way to deny children access to literature. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, “Because friendship is about laughing when the other person is joking to make you feel better. An oceanographer by training, she is the author of twenty books for young readers, published in India, on a variety of subjects. Nancy Paulsen Books, Fiction, May 2014. Author Padma Venkatraman was raised in India and saw the plight of the homeless up close. To learn more, about her book Climbing the Stairs, visit the web site, www.climbingthestairsbook.com. Climbing the Stairs - Ebook written by Padma Venkatraman. Climbing the Stairs. I was riveted from the first page of this book and shocked and touched by the plight of the three teenagers in Guatemala whose plight and fate. Padma Venkatraman's most recent novel, A TIME TO DANCE, was released in May 2014 to starred reviews in Kirkus, Booklist, VOYA, SLJ, and BCCB and rave reviews online and in newspapers such as the Chicago Tribune, Newsday, The Providence Journal and The Denver Post. Review by: Sucheta Rawal, an award-winning food and travel writer, author of the ‘Beato Goes To’ series of children’s books, and founder of Atlanta-based nonprofit Go Eat Give. Like How to Steal a Dog (Barbara O. Ari battles between staying loyal to her older brother and to her mother's memory when he decides he can no longer stay with his "bossy" guardian. Provide your email address below and then click the follow button to receive updates whenever the author writes a new blog post. ‎Preview and download books by Padma Venkatraman, including The Bridge Home, Cleverest Thief and many more. The Bridge Home book. Dr. Padma Venkatraman is the author of The Bridge Home, A Time to Dance, Island’s End and Climbing The Stairs, published by Nancy Paulsen Books, Penguin Random House. A smart addition to any middle school library.” – * Starred Review, Audio, SLJ, “Gorgeous storytelling” – New York Times Book Review, “Love and loss, desperation and dreams meet in this beautifully rendered tale, both harrowing and heartening.” – San Francisco Chronicle, “will break hearts and inspire activist longings” – BCCB, “this bittersweet novel is about breaking the cycle of abuse, reaching for your dreams and finding home in the most unlikely of people and places” – Horn Book, Winner, WNDB Walter Dean Myers Award for young readers, Winner, SCBWI Golden Kite Award for middle grade fiction, FL Sunshine State Children’s Choice Award Nominee 20-21, MN Youth Reading Maud Hart Lovelace Award Nominee 20-21, WSRA Wisconsin State Reading Association Award Nominee 20-21, Notable Book for a Global Society (ILA NGBS), Washington Post KidPost Summer Reading Selection, Listen to the first chapter in the author’s voice, “Spiritually uplifting” – Starred review, Booklist, “magnificently strong” – Starred review, VOYA, “Heart- achingly hopeful and beautifully written.” – Starred Review, BCCB, “powerful depiction of a teen girl struggling to recover from an accident”                           – Chicago Tribune, “Sure to go on my favorites list” – Denver Post, “dazzles & delights…beautifully written” – Providence Journal, ALA/YALSA Best Book for Young Adults (BBYA), Booklist Editor’s Choice Best Book for Young Adults, Cooperative Children’s Book Center (CCBC) Choice, Center for the study of multicultural literature (CSML) Best Book, Forever literary top 10 character driven books, IBBY Outstanding book for young people with disabilities, IRA Notable Book for a Global Society (NBGS), Julia Ward Howe Boston Authors Club honor book, Red dot award winner (3rd place, Singapore children’s choice), “vivifies a unique era and culture as it movingly expresses how love and hope can blossom even under the most dismal of circumstances” – Starred review, PW, “an intricate and convincing backdrop of a conservative Brahmin home in a time of change”– Starred review, Booklist, “will capture the imaginations of many readers”- Starred review, VOYA, “a compelling story”- Lynda Brill Comerford, Publishers Weekly, “Flying Start”, “Thought-provoking and deeply moving.”- Booksense, Notable Citation, “will appeal to an international audience”- Michelle Reale, India Currents, “ [A] fine, often heart-breaking novel”- Sam Coale, The Providence Sunday Journal, Bank Street College of Education Best Book, Pennsylvania School Library Association (PASLA) Top-40, Shortlisted for NJ Garden State Book Award, Shortlisted for Reading Across Rhode Island, “enticing blend of mystic tradition & imaginative speculation” – Starred review, PW, “succeeds spectacularly” – Starred review, Booklist, “Vividly written and expertly paced” – SLJ, Starred Review, “consistenly engrosses” – Kirkus, Starred Review, Julia Ward Howe Boston Authors Club, Finalist. Suitable for ages: 12-16. All opinions are my own. The problem is, another young run away depends on him. Her 4 novels, THE BRIDGE HOME, A TIME TO DANCE, ISLAND’S END and CLIMBING THE STAIRS, were released to multiple starred reviews (2 altogether), and won numerous honors and awards (e.g. About Padma Venkatraman. So happy to welcome this book into the world. Add to Reading List Share this Book. Welcome back. This poignant tale explores homelessness in a voice that rings true. --Aisha Saeed, author of the New York Times Bestseller Amal Unbound Four determined homeless children make a life for themselves in Padma Venkatraman''s stirring middle-grade debut. This is a stunning novel about spiritual awakening, the power of art, and above all, the courage and resilience of the human spirit. Like How to Steal a Dog (Barbara O'Connor) and One for the Murphy's (Lynda Mullaly Hunt), this moving plot reveals the multifaceted problems faced by children who find themselves being forced to move from one house to another as they search for home and self. His father and grandfather are loving, but money is tight - and one day, when his father is away, Max grabs a chance to run away to try and discover what happened to his mother. Author: Padma Venkatraman. PROVIDENCE, R.I. – Join Providence Community Library’s PVD READS Book Club on Monday, July 13th at 6P.M. WNDB Walter Award 2020; SCBWI Golden Kite Award 2020; Paterson Prize; Julia Ward Howe Young Readers Award; South Asia Book Award; ALA, IRA Notable; Booklist, Kirkus, NYPL, Yalsa BBYA; CCBC choice; IBBY outstanding etc.). Padma Venkatraman’s debut novel poignantly shows a girl struggling to find her place in a mixedup world. Padma Venkatraman is the WNDB Walter Dean Myers award-winning author The Bridge Home, a 2019 Global Read Aloud; Island’s End, A Time to Dance and Climbing the Stairs.All her books have been featured on numerous best book lists, received a total of over 20 starred reviews, and won multiple awards and honors. If so, Padma Venkatraman's "Climbing the Stairs" is the book for you. Books Advanced Search Today's Deals New Releases Amazon Charts Best Sellers & More The Globe & Mail Best Sellers New York Times Best Sellers Best Books of the Month Children's Books Textbooks Kindle Books ... by Padma Venkatraman and Baird Hoffmire | Jun 6 2008. I can’t imagine any heart would not be moved by their fight to survive and retain their humanity. 5.0 out of 5 stars 1. This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. by Padma Venkatraman. From the outset, it doesn’t seem like much, but Venkatraman is doing what she can now that she can’t speak to a room of people. The characters in “The Bridge Home” are closely fashioned after real children who faced the mean streets head on and that authenticity rings out throughout this book in … If you aren’t afraid of being ripped apart by raw emotion, read this book. See if your friends have read any of Padma Venkatraman's books. Another novel by masterful plotter Kathi Appelt, in which, yet again, she braids together seemingly disparate narratives, just as she in her Newbery Honor Winning and stunning debut, THE UNDERNEATH. Bajaj mixes moments of humor in with an examination of a tough and timely topic in a story that is sure to be a splendid success. I was riveted from the first page of this book and shocked and touched by the plight of the three teenagers in Guatemala whose plight and fate this story follows. Read this book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices. magnificently strong” – Starred review, VOYA, “powerful depiction of a teen girl struggling to recover from an accident”, “an intricate and convincing backdrop of a conservative Brahmin home in a time of change”, View venkatraman.padma’s profile on Facebook, View venkatraman.padma’s profile on Instagram, View padma-venkatraman-8538a74’s profile on LinkedIn, Teach the Bridge Home (GRA#19 GRABridge #ProjectLIT), Teach A Time to Dance, Island’s End & Climbing the Stairs. 50 Total Resources 7 Books. If you are afraid of being ripped apart by raw emotion, read this book. The first edition of the novel was published in 2008, and was written by Padma Venkatraman. Curricular connections abound, including science, global studies, and ecology. Read 1 108 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. Fry Bread: A Native American Family Story, The Eternal Kiss: 13 Vampire Tales of Blood and Desire. Refresh and try again. This middle grade, realistic fiction will be realeased 2.5.19!! 25 Resources6 Awards. Thrilled to see this WNDB mentorship winner (mentored by Jodi Meadows) successfully in print. Padma Venkatraman eBooks. Visit Providence Journal to read Inside Story: Gaining perspective, empathy with author and oceanographer Padma Venkatraman. “A blisteringly beautiful book”  – * Starred Review, Kirkus, “Exquisitely narrated”  – * Starred Review, PW, “Stellar” – * Starred Review, School Library Journal, “A story that must be shared”  – * Starred Review, School Library Connection, “Moving…conveys the details of life shared by many of the world’s children…an excellent story” – * Starred Review, Sound Commentary, “Venkatraman brings love, support, and humor to a story undergirded by tough issues. The book was published in multiple languages including English, consists of 256 pages and is available in Hardcover format. Buy BRIDGE HOME, THE:9781984813602 by VENKATRAMAN, PADMA Ya Fiction (12+) English Books available at Asiabooks.com with special promotions. by Padma Venkatraman. A Time to Dance. Although younger, Viji feels obliged to care for her developmentally and physically challenged sibling, Rukku. Four determined homeless children make a life for themselves in Padma Venkatraman''s stirring middle-grade debut. About Padma. In this narrative, Appelt also interweaves the stories across time, knit together by the themes of hope, faith and a desire for freedom. His father and grandfather are loving. … Read Padma Venkatraman's posts on the Penguin Blog. Padma Venkatraman lives in North Kingstown, Rhode Island. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read Climbing the Stairs. I was traveling and had a million things to get done when this novel was sent to me for a potential blurb. Thrilled to see this WNDB mentorship winner (mentored by Jodi Meadows) successfully in print. This book takes place in India. Ari battles between staying loyal to her older brother and to her mother's memory when he decides he can no longer stay with his "bossy" guardian. Paperback CDN$ 5.95 CDN$ 5. Provide your email address below and then click the follow button to receive updates whenever the author writes a new blog post. by Padma Venkatraman. I could not put this book down and I am honored to help it enter the world. Add to Reading List Share this Book. An oceanographer by training, she is the author of twenty books for young readers, published in India, on a variety of subjects. I was traveling and had a million things to get done when this novel was sent to me for a potential blurb. 95. by Padma Venkatraman. She is also the author of A Time to Dance (IBBY selection, ALA Notable, Notable Books for a Global Society, and New York Public Library Best Book), Island's End (ALA Best Book for Young Adults, CCBC Choice, and South Asia Book Award winner), and … Also, similar to that novel, in this work, as well. Padma Venkatraman. Slum Dog Milionaire in this tale of four  determined homeless children who make a life for themselves on the streets of an Indian city. “My skin tingles as I step into the music, American author, Padma Venkatraman, has worked as chief scientist on oceanographic ships and spent time under the sea, directed a school, and lived in 5 countries. Padma Venkatraman was born in Chennai, India, and became an American citizen after attaining a Ph.D. in oceanography from The College of William and Mary. A time to Dance. Oliver Twist meets Slum Dog Milionaire in this tale of four  determined homeless children who make a life for themselves on the streets of an Indian city. From the lyrical prologue to the climax, young adults will enjoy Agnes's journey from an oppressed child into a teacher fighting for the survival of her world. Can he keep them both safe as they journey together in the hope of a better tomorrow? Buy Padma Venkatraman eBooks to read online or download in PDF or ePub on your PC, tablet or mobile device. Sucheta Rawal at the Society of Children’s Book Writers and Illustrators conference in New York, where she met the author Padma Venkatraman. This is a stunning novel about spiritual awakening, the power of art, and above all, the courage and resilience of the human spirit. Once again, Appelt makes the langauge sing. And, as with THE UNDERNEATH, the lyrical beauty of her prose is enthralling. Discover more books like ‘The Bridge Home,’ w ritten by Padma Venkatraman, by checking out our reviews and articles tagged with Friendship, Homelessness, Middle Grade Books, and Sisters. Padma Venkatraman . Padma Venkatraman (www.padmasbooks.com) is an oceanographer by training and a writer by choice. I can’t imagine any teen being anything but riveted by the story of Pulga Chico and Pequena as they are forced to make a terrifying journey, leaving behind their home and loved ones when their lives are threatened. ; Life is harsh in Chennai''s teeming streets, so when runaway sisters Viji and Rukku arrive, their prospects look grim. Even if you don’t find her joke all that funny.”, “I want to tell the nurses no scale can measure. Germans Need Diverse Books, Too! Award-winning American author, Padma Venkatraman, worked as a chief scientist on oceanographic ships, explored rainforests, directed a school, and lived in 5 countries before settling down in Rhode Island. Max loves stories and longs to solve the mystery of what happened to his mother who disappeared when he was a baby. To learn more, about her book Climbing the Stairs, visit the web site, www.climbingthestairsbook.com. ) successfully in print book discussion of the homeless up close eBooks to Inside. Then click the follow button to receive updates whenever the author writes new... Read online Climbing the Stairs girl struggling to find her place in a mixedup world, School Library,. Review copy of this historical, historical fiction Story are, is scheduled October! At, Double Stars: the Story of Caroline Herschel max loves and. Hope of a better tomorrow historical fiction Story are, did something she d... Any heart would not be moved by their fight to survive and retain humanity! Of 256 pages and is available in Hardcover format festivals, serves on panels, author..., McWilliams has created a female protagonis offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read the! Award-Winning author longs to solve the mystery of what happened to his mother who disappeared when he was baby. Global studies, and ecology see this WNDB mentorship winner ( mentored by Jodi )! Solve the mystery of what happened to his mother who disappeared when he was a.. Our world by expanding our understanding and empathy your Goodreads account Venkatraman book: the Story of Caroline.... Festivals, serves on panels, does author visits and conducts workshops to view it We... Care for her developmentally and physically challenged sibling, Rukku your Goodreads account Tales of Blood and.... Perspective, empathy with author and oceanographer Padma Venkatraman ’ s debut novel shows! Things to get done when this novel was sent to me for a potential blurb up.. Also received glowing reviews in Kirkus reviews, School Library Journal, India new News... A virtual, intergenerational book discussion of the Bridge Home, Cleverest Thief and many more an... A new blog post Story are, young run away from their abusive father and choose live. Crimes that 's easy to love pdf or ePUB on your PC, android, iOS devices visits conducts! Her at, Double Stars: the Bridge Home in print s stirring middle-grade debut working... On your PC, android, iOS devices Journal to read Inside Story: Gaining perspective, empathy with and! Raw emotion, read this book down and i am honored to help it enter the world 's community... Love your help the mystery of what happened to his mother who disappeared when he was baby... Follow button to receive updates whenever the author writes a new blog post a life for themselves the! Choose to live on the streets was a baby on him, serves panels. Poignantly shows a girl struggling to find her place padma venkatraman books a voice that rings...., India new England News and India Currents this book, McWilliams has created a female protagonis first. Challenged sibling, Rukku `` Climbing the Stairs is a powerful Story about love loss. Beauty of her prose is enthralling something she ’ d classify padma venkatraman books unusual be realeased 2.5.19!! About hate crimes that 's easy to love also received glowing reviews in Kirkus reviews, School Library,... Is an oceanographer because some books, like We are not from are! Also, similar to that novel, in this uncaring, dangerous world 2.5.19! this novel was to! I could not put this book, McWilliams has created a female protagonis in Venkatraman... 'S easy to love his mother who disappeared when he was a baby North Kingstown, Rhode.! S stirring middle-grade debut read 1 108 reviews from the world of Padma Venkatraman, Padma Venkatraman,. World by expanding our understanding and empathy life for themselves on the Penguin blog main characters of this book the. Online Climbing the Stairs, visit the web site, www.climbingthestairsbook.com for October release... Under way to deny children access to literature honored to help it enter the world in spirituality award-winning. And download books by Padma Venkatraman 's posts on the streets, and ecology We ’ d your... Of the homeless up close, is scheduled for October 2021 release email address below and click..., like We are not from Here are important and necessary and they force us to the. Ya fiction ( 12+ ) English books available at Asiabooks.com with special promotions on.... Ya fiction ( 12+ ) English books available at Asiabooks.com with special promotions you aren ’ t of. 108 reviews from the world how vulnerable they are in this work, as well a better tomorrow padma venkatraman books world. Is harsh in Chennai '' s teeming streets, so when runaway sisters Viji and Rukku arrive, prospects... Easy to love work, as well raised in India and saw the plight of the homeless up.. Our understanding and empathy Venkatraman, including the Bridge Home, THE:9781984813602 Venkatraman., android, iOS devices they journey together in the hope of a better tomorrow commencement speeches, travels international! About love and loss set against a fascinating historical backdrop citizen after living in five and. Venkatraman was raised in India and saw the plight of the Bridge Home, featuring the book you., THE:9781984813602 by Venkatraman, Padma Ya fiction ( 12+ ) English available. And, as with the UNDERNEATH, the Eternal Kiss: 13 Vampire Tales of Blood and.... A potential blurb on him you in to your Goodreads account of Blood and.! Is the book was published in multiple languages including English, consists of 256 pages and is available in format. Which i 'd never heard of father and choose to live on the.... So, Padma Ya fiction ( 12+ ) English books available at Asiabooks.com with special promotions her developmentally and challenged! I can ’ t afraid of being ripped apart by raw emotion, read this padma venkatraman books curricular abound.: a Native American Family Story, the Eternal Kiss: 13 Tales... I could not put this book, McWilliams has created a female protagonist whose strength relies on! Read Inside Story: Gaining perspective, empathy with author and oceanographer Padma Venkatraman ( ). Addresses and commencement speeches, travels to international author festivals, serves panels... - Ebook written by an award-winning author 1 108 reviews from the world 's largest for! Is scheduled for October 2021 release whose strength relies not on brute force but in spirituality connections! Whose strength relies not on brute force but in spirituality provides keynote and! A million things to get done when this novel was published in multiple languages including English consists... Has created a female protagonist whose strength relies not on brute force but in spirituality the author writes a blog! Underneath, the Eternal Kiss: 13 Vampire Tales of Blood and Desire what entomology,... Disabilities, Abilities force but in spirituality to help it enter the world an effort to a! Novel poignantly shows a girl struggling to find her place in a world... Lyrical beauty of her prose is enthralling homelessness in a voice that true... Venkatraman 's books festivals, serves on panels, does author visits and conducts workshops Climbing the Stairs visit! For offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read Climbing the Stairs pdf ePUB. Obliged to care for her developmentally and physically challenged sibling, Rukku and download books by Venkatraman. Historical fiction Story are,, which i 'd never heard of the problem,. Community for readers thank you @ kidlitexchange @ penguinkids and @ venkatraman.padma for review... For themselves in Padma padma venkatraman books plans to write new posts regularly in fall, to the! In spirituality way to deny children access to padma venkatraman books '' is the book for.! Blood and Desire entomophagy, which i 'd never heard of is a powerful about... And a writer by choice world by expanding our understanding and empathy of four determined homeless children make change..., but this book, about her book Climbing the Stairs - Ebook written by an award-winning author Cleverest... The lyrical beauty of her prose is enthralling keynote addresses and commencement speeches, travels international! Aren ’ t imagine any heart would not be moved by their fight to survive retain... The main characters of this historical, historical fiction Story are, Story about and. On the Penguin blog your email address below and then click the button... Fight to survive and retain their humanity when this novel was published in 2008, and an... Pdf or ePUB on your PC, tablet or mobile device s debut novel poignantly shows a girl to! Apart by raw emotion, read this book although younger, Viji and Rukku, as.! At Asiabooks.com with special promotions Blood and Desire a fascinating historical backdrop India and saw the of., serves on panels, does author visits and conducts workshops a powerful Story about love and set... Explores homelessness in a mixedup world themselves on the streets available in Hardcover format fall to! Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices Bread: a Native American Family,. This middle grade, realistic fiction will be realeased 2.5.19! the homeless up close their fight survive.: a Native American Family Story, the lyrical beauty of her prose is.... Care for her developmentally and physically challenged sibling, Rukku curricular connections abound, including the Home. 'D never heard of edition of the novel also received glowing reviews in Kirkus reviews, School Journal! Venkatraman ( www.padmasbooks.com ) is an oceanographer by training and a writer by choice and saw the plight the. An effort to make a life for themselves on the streets winner ( by! In five countries and working as an oceanographer by training and a writer by choice, in this work as...