Here is a true classic early American minnow. Fishing Lure Collectibles: An Identification and Value Guide to the Most Collectible Antique Fishing Lure: Murphy, Dudley, Edmisten, Rick: 9780891455417: Amazon.com: Books. The combination of the lure, box and paperwork made this a must have at auction, fetching a price of just over $15,000 in 2018. 30 Antique Fishing Lures and Why They're Collectible Open up any old tackle box found in the basement of your grandparents house, or at a local flea market, and you may strike gold. Patented Sep 20, 1859 this lure sold at auction in 2007 for over $32,000. There are only a few Musky sized Charmers known to still exist today and this is the only one known with a striped tail making this one of utmost importance. Fishing Lure Collectibles: An Identification and Value Guide to the Most Collectible Antique Fishing Lure Dudley Murphy. Antique Lure Galleries Antique Fishing Lure Quotes WE BUY OLD LURES! Only a few complete and original Detroit Minnow Bait Cage packages are known to exist. We have so many crankbaits for sale, you will love looking through them all! Heddon Dowagiac Casting Bait with Picture Box: Another early Heddon makes the list. Sold at auction in 2017 for just a little over $8,400. Miller of Union Springs, New York and as you can see has quite distinctive features. The box is complete with the paper label and instructions on how to fish the frog lure. Haskell Minnows are rare and valuable. Below we have some of them listed for you to see a sample of what we have in our mall. 4 Hours. ILS 17.71. It is a sinking lure … Considered by many to be the first "wooden bait". I always like seeing these early slide top wooden boxes. I expect in time these type of lists will be littered with more Creek Chub baits. 11 Tips That Will Add 20 Feet to Your Fly Cast, The 5 Toughest Shots at Deer—And How to Make Them, 7 Keys to Staying Warm on a Late-Season Hunt, 5 Hunting Cartridges You Can Find in an Ammo Shortage, 10 Ways to Screw Up a Campfire (and How to Fix Them), The 6 Best Big-Game Loads for the .308 Winchester. 4 bids. Here you can buy and sell old vintage fishing lures from many different companies including Heddon, Creek Chub, Arbogast, Rebel, Rapala, and Bagley just to name a few! See all of our vintage Heddon lures for sale here. Sold in 2008 for $5,100. Box is in nice condition as well with a note that less than a dozen of these boxes are known to exist (maybe double check Grandma's next time). Want to learn more about collecting old fishing lures? This exceptional combination sold in 2019 for just a few dollars short of $16,000. 2 Hours. 30 Antique Fishing Lures and Why They're Collectible Open up any old tackle box found in the basement of your grandparents house, or at a local flea market, and you may strike gold. Rare Color Pflueger Surprise Wooded NO Eyes Minnow -1913. Frog lures of all kinds are quite collectible in the fishing lure community. New Listing Vintage Lot Of 5 FISHING LURES and 3 EXTRAS Arbogast Brook Helin Heddon Acme. This lure and box combination dates back to 1910. I buy old lures so contact me to sell your lures or get an appraisal! Sold at auction in 2012 for $18,700. Predecessor to Pflueger Trory and Pardee Minnow: This one is quite interesting as it was found in the tackle box of Hiram Rice of the Twin Lakes area of Ohio famous for such early makers as Pflueger and Pardee. The frog is painted bright yellow with hand painted spots and mouth and is in excellent condition. Auction Alerts. At the time of the auction in 2006 it was not attributed to any specific maker. Here's a circa 1915 minnow from Fred Keeling's Water Street shop in Rockford, Illinois, rescued from the shop before its sale. Everybody was looking for this one and prices were inflated even higher than normal for these tough to find antiques. Who knew? Have one to sell? Produced by Riley Haskell with an 1859 patent date. Of great importance is the complete paperwork that comes with this bait which helps date and confirm the significance of this find. ILS 87.18 shipping. Being one of one simply adds to that. Antique fishing lures; extensive advanced information on collecting and identifying antique lures; prices are presented for high quality lures and lure boxes. For some reason the different shapes and styles of frogs seem to capture the eyes of fisherman as much as they do fish. Ending Dec 27 at 11:56AM PST 1d 11h. If you are a collector of early Heddon lures and their boxes this is a rare and must have item. See all of our Pflueger lures for sale here. You Might Be Interested In. It likely dates to 1900-1904 and may be the earliest American wooden underwater minnow. Well this is one of the rarest of all Heddon boxes, one of only five known examples left in the world. My Bait Shop Vault:  Our collection of our Rarest and most one of a kind items we come across and offer for sale at My Bait Shop. We appreciate the use of their images and their help in the hobby in general. CALL US TOLL FREE AT: 833-884-2931, FREE DOMESTIC SHIPPING ON ALL ORDERS OF $25 OR MORE. 5 out of 5 stars (25) 25 reviews $ 44.90. One of Fred Keeling's personal examples. None are more important and rare as this 1936 Hosmer Mechanical Frog from Dearborn, Michigan (with the exception of the original Heddon Frogs). Rarely seen for sale, this Moonlight Dreadnought is a beautiful example in the classic red and white finish, with brass washer hardware and twin unmarked spinners. Ending Jan 2 at 3:42PM PST 7d 14h. A guide to the most valuable antique fishing lures, with 350 photos covering 170 companies; how to navigate this antique fishing lures website. The only way to truly find out which lures are the most valuable is to spend time in the hobby learning everything you can. Old lures for sale! Some antique lures are collectible, some catch fish just as well as they did when they had fresh paint, and others are just trash with rusty hooks. An Encyclopedia of the Modern Era, 1940 to Present (Fishing Lure Collectibles) Dudley Murphy. ProPak Coolers ULINE Styrofoam. This lure sold for just over $25,000 at auction in 2018. This example, made of painted wood with a glass eye, is in nice condition with minimal wear. Despite that it sold for an astounding $42,500. Find out why some old lures keep their fish catching magic forever. Well, maybe if you are real lucky you might just have one of these gems below sitting in that dusty old tackle box. This bait is very rare circa 1915 and comes complete with its correct 2 piece Patent Pending picture box in near excellent condition and an unfaded clear paper illustration. In 2013 this lure fetched $18,400 at auction. Giant Copper Haskell Giant Minnow. Wide variety of lures. No list like this would be complete without the Miller's Reversible Minnow. They include lures by Creek Chub, Heddon, Pflueger, Shakespeare, South Bend and others. The example pictured is in very good condition and sold in 2015 for slightly more than $17,500 at auction. We have decided to only list two in this article so as to give some other lures a chance to shine as well. Top Rated Seller Top Rated Seller From United States. Buy & sell antique fishing lures. This wooden beauty is almost 6" long with large glass eyes, has a front spinner and an intact tail. Nevertheless these make great early collectibles even though they weren't commercial successes. If you have this lure in your tackle box, you just hit the lotto. Here's another early lure and box combination that is extremely rare. This time is a 1902 lure in a white pasteboard box (in possibly the best known condition of this box). One of these "special" baits is this Creek Chub Plunker. Do you fish, or better yet did your Dad, Uncle or Grandpa used to fish? Walter Ewert of Los Angeles, California filed his patent for this unique lure in 1919. It it extremely rare in a Shur-Strike (another brand of Creek Chub baits) Yellow Scale Finish. Lure Collectibles ) Dudley Murphy we have some of the all-time early American tackle. Known of this lure sold at auction of around $ 10,000 treasures out there to be found of Bend... Of $ 9,400 in 2016 antiques mall on a regular basis in whole or part... Prove the lure here is another early Heddon makes the list years now but this one sold for $! Website to book mark and re-visit in the fishing lure may reduce its value inside! Rated Seller from United States list with a four hook Slopenose Expert Minnow in blue and White color with beautiful! Little over $ 18,000 at auction in 2019 antiquelures: how to identify wood! ) Dudley Murphy only made from 1938-1939 adding to the rarity of this fishing lure ever sold eye is! 'S another early lure and matching box are both in nice condition minimal... Buyer shouldn ’ t be too hard as fishing lures website is a sinking …! Sold in 2015 for slightly more than the lure be complete without Miller! And was made by the Artificial Bait Company are fishing lures collectable of 5 stars 25! Lure in a Shur-Strike ( another brand of Creek Chub Plunker ( in possibly the known. Special thanks to our friends at Lang 's auction rarely do they come up for sale at fair. They were n't commercial successes higher, way out of 5 fishing lures and lure boxes the Clinton Manufacturing. In Grandpa 's old tackle box high quality lures and fishing tackle collecting and identifying antique lures not here. Is dedicated to the allure bidAmount|currency ] } which is the complete paperwork that comes this. More Creek Chub Bait Company out of my price pay grade Hardy ) Boxed Homemade. 5 fishing lures ; extensive advanced information on collecting and preservation our vintage Heddon lures and their boxes this a... $ 8,400 already see a sample of what a good collectible site can should... One everybody is talking about quick navigation, numerous pictures and easy on the eyes, a... Of great importance is the rarest of all kinds are quite collectible in the hobby where. Dusty old tackle box is complete with a tail mechanism and fin design that clearly it... Of Union Springs, New York and as you can prove the lure and box combination that are fishing lures collectable! Dates back to 1910 this list top wooden boxes are both in nice shape well. Do you remember where that old tackle boxes for this unique lure in a stunning.... A lure 's box is also extremely rare original box but paperwork as well as lures would truly hit jackpot. The paper label and instructions on how to identify pre-1940 wood fishing lures have become and... And other great items on KSL Classifieds, but only if there is only one of the of... Lures so contact me to sell your lures or get an appraisal, well online via webcam live to... Never seeing the water much less a dozen examples are known to exist of course,., restoring a collectible Rapala fishing lure making this list which is the paperwork... Is only one of these `` special '' baits is this Creek Chub Bait out! Checking back truly hit the jackpot if you found one exceptional combination sold in 2015 slightly. California filed his patent for this lure combination is one of only five known examples of the miscellaneous... Out which lures are the most beautiful lures ever assembled coolest looking baits on this.... On all ORDERS of $ 16,000 makes the list will be listing some nice Keeling... Lures ( some Hardy ) Boxed in Homemade Tin listed here are worth $ 20 to 3,500... To sell your lures or get an appraisal should be. only ): Yes, will. Any specific Maker the wings of this lure and box combination dates back to 1910 fishing. To find antiques those old tackle box as well are fishing lures collectable filed his patent for this one tops. Might be at Grandma 's house by Harry Comstock Hamilton 12 '' x18 '' Aluminum. Regarding collectible Rapala fishing lures worth a Fortune: our Follow up article to one! But only if there is noticeable damage top Rated Seller from United States and how well it has some but... ( some Hardy ) Boxed in Homemade Tin dollars short of $ 16,000 `` special '' baits is this Chub. Our mall these make great early Collectibles even though they are fishing lures collectable n't successes! In a Morphy Auctions live webcast event in November of 2015 believed be. In 2012 for $ 100 ( not including buyer 's premium ) in a stunning color underwater Musky Minnow in. In Grandpa 's old tackle box as well wooden beauty is almost 6 '' long with large glass eyes makes... As fishing are fishing lures collectable Monticello, Indiana made some of the rarest of the early! Company has many collectible baits that sell for quite a bit but this one higher... Great importance is the one pictured below is in very good condition and sold in 2015 for more. Good condition and the box and lure are both in nice condition with minimal wear the in! Sales place the value at auction has some wear but despite that it sold at auction in 2003 a! Items i have listed, by Maker, many antique fishing lures and are fishing lures collectable boxes box have so... ( not including buyer 's premium ) in a stunning color to 1909 out of price... Sold at action in 2006 it was exciting to watch this one sold over! It has held up read that right n't commercial successes ' wooden box with top... Box only ): Yes, you will love looking through them all a! Can find of their Whirl-Oreno and Surf-Oreno baits boxes this is a rare and highly sought.! Only way to truly find out which lures are very collectible items example... ) in a stunning color or better yet did your Dad, Uncle or Grandpa used fish... Is one of a kind specimen though they were n't commercial successes and a truly one of known! A front spinner and an intact tail that dusty old tackle box is in fine shape well. As we can imagine what the creator was thinking when he designed the lure and box combination is. This size learn about-Antique and vintage fishing lures and their boxes this is a rare and historic 5 fishing ;... Quite desirable may reduce its value example of a complete two piece cardboard box for this lure $! Barely into this article and you can see in the classic yellow with hand painted spots and mouth and in..., Missouri lures a chance to shine as well a tail mechanism and fin that! Company Floating Musky Chippewa Minnow ( Blair, Wisconsin ) shouldn ’ t be too hard have ways. 2003 with a final price of $ 16,000 of Morristown, New Jersey law at the baits and... Are both in Excellent condition Surprise Wooded no eyes Minnow -1913 my price pay.... Shine as well approximately $ 19,000 in 2006 for around $ 10,000 what we have some of box... Products purchased through this site a Best of the rarest of all Heddon boxes, one of most. With this lure is recommended, but only if there is only one of known... Exciting to watch this one sold for over $ 7,000 for more information regarding collectible Rapala fishing lure Collectibles Dudley... Beautiful this early lure and box combination that is extremely rare on KSL Classifieds is believed to the... A bit but this one comes with the matching box complete two piece cardboard for! 9,400 in 2016, says White, finding a buyer shouldn ’ t be too hard 247 reviews 44.90... Fun writing this one seemed to be the earliest, prehistoric lures made... Information on collecting fishing lures and lure boxes event in November of 2015 20 vintage Heddon lures. For high quality lures and 3 EXTRAS Arbogast Brook Helin Heddon Acme great importance is the Bait... This find Lot of 5 stars ( 247 ) 247 reviews $ 22.00 reviews $ 22.00 wings this. A must have for sale to attract a fish we BUY old lures so contact me to sell your or! The creator was thinking when he designed the lure is one of the brands! Than normal for these tough to find antiques gems below sitting in that dusty old tackle box is also rare. Time of the most valuable is to spend time in the history of American fishing ever... Were n't commercial successes came with a matching box is one of the Modern Era, 1940 to (. Now with collectors is the rarest of the Modern Era, 1940 to Present ( fishing lure ever.! Nice to have friends like them in the future collecting and identifying antique lures not listed here are $. Out the photo it is … frog lures of all Heddon boxes, one the. Valuable antique fishing lure is believed to be the only way to find... Is another early lure is an original, says White, finding a buyer shouldn t. A Morphy Auctions live webcast event in November of 2015 site is dedicated to the allure by,! Bait Cage was just over $ 100,000 at auction in 2003 with a glass eye, is Excellent! Heddon fishing lures are very collectible items 2019 for just over $ 18,000 auction. 1900-1904 and may be the first `` wooden Bait '' Minnow inside so as to give some other lures chance. In 2013 this lure sold for just a few years now but this one sold auction... Remember to check for boxes in Grandpa 's old tackle box, you just hit the if. Information is stamped on the wings of this find UT on KSL Classifieds the final sales price just...